Choosing a Power Management IC for Energy-Harvesting Applications

By Bill Schweber

Contributed By Electronic Products

The power-management IC (PMIC) supports and manages the transducer and energy-collection channel, the energy-storage element (battery, conventional capacitor or supercapacitor), and the processor/wireless link. This critical block of any energy-harvesting design implements several major functions:
  • Captures and extracts the random, miniscule energy from the source transducer
  • Transforms that extracted power into energy for the storage element, usually via a DC/DC converter
  • Manages the outflow of power from the storage element, while ensuring that power is not drawn when the stored energy is below a threshold value and would be wasted
  • Perhaps most challenging, it has to manage its own start-up sequence in the transition from when there is insufficient available stored energy for the PMIC itself
For designers of energy-harvesting systems, there is good news: a wider choice of PMICs is now available from vendors, each with differing attributes and characteristics. Some are optimized for a specific harvesting source, while others are more general; some fulfill primarily one part of the PMIC role, while others integrate more of the essential functions.

Engineers should always keep in mind that all energy-harvesting designs are based on one principle – to accumulate over time the trickle of minuscule, sporadic energy from the source, store it, and then release it as a power pulse when needed by the rest of the system for data collection, analysis and transmission. Therefore, there are long quiescent periods when the PMIC's only activity is to allow the energy to flow to the storage element and little else, as well as periods when there is no incoming energy.

You must also be aware that a conventional DC/DC switching converter core, no matter how efficient, is generally not a good choice for energy harvesting. This is because these are designed to work with a consistent source such as battery, which is a low-impedance, somewhat regulated source. Further, the DC/DC switching converter of a PMIC must have extremely low quiescent current requirements, as there may be long periods without available source energy and thus no power-converter activity.

Maxim’s MAX17710

The Maxim MAX17710 accepts energy from a variety of transducers, manages the charging of the energy-storage element, and provides a regulated DC output to the load (Figure 1). It is optimized to work with the THINERGY ultra-thin, postage-stamp-sized micro-energy cell (MEC) rechargeable battery from Infinite Power Solutions. When no harvesting source is present, the quiescent battery drain of this IC is under 1 nA, thus increasing the likelihood that enough battery power will remain for basic operation even after a long period of harvest inactivity.

The part includes protection for the battery against undervoltage and overvoltage conditions, which many batteries – especially the very small ones used for harvesting – cannot tolerate. For the first problem, the MAX17710 locks out any load drain to prevent overdischarge of the MEC (which may damage the MEC), and unlocks it only when the harvesting source has delivered enough energy to the MEC and raised its voltage. For overvoltage conditions, which may be due to excessive charging or component failure, it regulates the input voltage and shunts excess power away from the MEC.

Maxim MAX17710

Figure 1: The Maxim MAX17710 is designed to primarily work with one battery vendor's component, but the harvested energy can come from a variety of sources.

Linear Technology’s LTC3588 series

The LTC3588 is an energy-harvesting power supply, which is designed for use with vibration-sensitive piezoelectric transducers with their high output impedance and relatively high output voltage (up to about 20 V). By combining a full-wave bridge rectifier and a buck converter, both in low-loss implementations and undervoltage lockout functions with wide hysteresis, it directs charge from the transducer to accumulate on an input capacitor. Then, when there is enough charge for the buck converter to operate efficiently, it directs the stored charge to the output (Figure 2).

Linear Technology LTC3588

Figure 2: The start-up profile of the Linear Technology LTC3588, designed for piezoelectric source harvesting, shows how it manages the difficult transition as it accumulates enough energy for its own operation.

Texas Instruments’ bq25504

In contrast to the piezoelectric transducer, photovoltaic (PV, or solar cell) or thermoelectric generators (TEG) are low-voltage, high-impedance sources. The bq25504 (Figure 3) is centered on a boost converter/charger which starts when the input voltage is as low as 330 mV, and then will continue to function with VIN as low as 80 mV.

Since it is designed for sources such as solar cells, this device implements an algorithm to operate at the optimal energy-extraction and transfer point, called maximum peak power or power point tracking (MPP or MPPT), which matches the source impedance with the load impedance. For a PV source, the MPP is typically at 80 percent of the open-circuit voltage. For enhanced efficiency, the bq25504 lets the system microcontroller externally establish the MPP level; this also allows use of the bq25504 with other sources, such as the ambient electric field, which have different MPPs.

Texas Instruments bq25504

Figure 3: Optimized for solar (photovoltaic) and thermal sources, the Texas Instruments bq25504 implements an MPP algorithm but also lets the user set the MPP point.

Cymbet’s CBC915

In contrast to PMICs which are designed for one or just a few types of energy sources, the CBC915 EnerChip™ EP Energy Processor is designed to be used with almost any energy source, including vibration, light, thermal, RF induction, or EM fields. It incorporates a sophisticated MPPT approach, which dynamically matches the output impedance of the transducer to the input impedance of the power-conversion stage (Figure 4); in contrast, some PMIC collection topologies use a simpler but less efficient "charge accumulation" approach. When you are only collecting nanojoules of harvested energy, even a few percentage points of improvement can be critical.

Cymbet CBC915

Figure 4: A sophisticated harvesting PMIC such as the Cymbet CBC915 is well suited to sources such as PV cells, where the power curve is highly nonlinear, thus connecting the cell to a load that is not matched to its impedance results in inefficient power transfer.

Why would a designer use a more general-purpose PMIC such as this one? There are several reasons: the specific harvesting transducer may not be known in advance; the end-product is intended to be used with a variety of sources and use of this type of PMIC simplifies the bill of materials (BOM); or the user wants access to more advanced MPP control for that last extra bit of performance.

The CBC915 also includes a serial UART for communication to/from the system microcontroller. Using this interface, it can accept basic operational commands and also report back on key status indicators.

Factors to consider

When choosing a PMIC for harvesting applications, it is vital to look at the detailed specifications, of course. But along with that, there are broader questions to consider:
  • Do you want a transducer-specific PMIC or one which can be tailored to different harvesting sources?
  • What level of power management and algorithm sophistication is needed?
  • What amount of processor control/status with the PMIC is preferred?
  • What source duty cycle do you expect: as little as a few seconds per hour, or much more?

The power-management IC (PMIC) is one of the major blocks of an energy-harvesting design, along with the transducer and energy-collection channel, the processor/wireless link, and the energy-storage element (battery or supercapacitor). All four of these blocks are now seeing new product introductions from multiple vendors, as new harvesting opportunities stimulate innovation in the others. This article has reviewed recent developments in PMICs from various vendors, along with their key attributes and capabilities. For more information on the parts discussed, use the provided links to access product pages on the Digi-Key website.

Further Reading
  1. TechZone article, “Power Management ICs Simplify Integration of Supercapacitors in Energy Microharvesting Designs
  2. TechZone article, “Managing the Energy and Lifetimes of Thin-Film Batteries
  3. TechZone article, “A Hands-on Look at the Maxim MAX17710 Energy Harvesting PMIC
  4. TechZone article, “Optimal Power Management Techniques in Energy Harvesting Designs

Disclaimer: The opinions, beliefs, and viewpoints expressed by the various authors and/or forum participants on this website do not necessarily reflect the opinions, beliefs, and viewpoints of Digi-Key Electronics or official policies of Digi-Key Electronics.

About this author

Bill Schweber

Bill Schweber is an electronics engineer who has written three textbooks on electronic communications systems, as well as hundreds of technical articles, opinion columns, and product features. In past roles, he worked as a technical web-site manager for multiple topic-specific sites for EE Times, as well as both the Executive Editor and Analog Editor at EDN.

At Analog Devices, Inc. (a leading vendor of analog and mixed-signal ICs), Bill was in marketing communications (public relations); as a result, he has been on both sides of the technical PR function, presenting company products, stories, and messages to the media and also as the recipient of these.

Prior to the MarCom role at Analog, Bill was associate editor of their respected technical journal, and also worked in their product marketing and applications engineering groups. Before those roles, Bill was at Instron Corp., doing hands-on analog- and power-circuit design and systems integration for materials-testing machine controls.

He has an MSEE (Univ. of Mass) and BSEE (Columbia Univ.), is a Registered Professional Engineer, and holds an Advanced Class amateur radio license. Bill has also planned, written, and presented on-line courses on a variety of engineering topics, including MOSFET basics, ADC selection, and driving LEDs.

About this publisher

Electronic Products

Electronic Products magazine and serves engineers and engineering managers responsible for designing electronic equipment and systems.