Skip navigation
TechXchange
Digi-Key TechXchange Communities > Projects and Designs > Discussions
Up to Discussions in  Projects and Designs
10736 Views 3 Replies Latest reply: Feb 16, 2012 12:04 PM by John63 RSS
Light_Obsession Novice
Light_Obsession
Currently Being Moderated

Feb 6, 2012 2:15 PM

What makes an electrical engineer GOOD at lighting design.

I'm looking for what character traits, job experiences, or technical knowledge make a P.Eng(professional Engineer) good at lighting design?

Design, IE: drawing single-line diagrams, consulting with clients, etc.

Attachments:
Tags: lighting, engineering, light, electrical, engineer, lighting_design, lamp, lamps, diagrams, diagram, experience, electrical_engineer
  • John63 Novice
    John63
    10 posts since
    Feb 10, 2012
    Currently Being Moderated
    Feb 14, 2012 2:29 PM (in response to Light_Obsession)
    What makes an electrical engineer GOOD at lighting design.

    I think you have to have an "artsy" side to you.  For example much of how we experience light is subjective and can sometimes be downright emotional.  You need a feel for psychology and physiology to be a good lighting designer.  This is based on my experience doing lighting for live theater and also (waaaaay back when) for rock and pop concerts.  The technical end of lighting design is far easier to pick up than the perceptual part.  For example, in theater, we use a rose colored lighting (I am understating the actual gel combinations) for daylight.  It is no where near 5,500K!  But it gives the perception of natural daylight on stage.  On the other hand, 5,500K makes everyone on stage look like they are dead.  As a photographer, I find that I also have a feel for light and shadows and how they play against each other.  I don't think they teach that in engineering school.  I learned from working with some very good photographers.

     

    To answer your question then.  In addition to a PE in EE, you might want to be able to show theater,  video (almost forgot that one) and photography lighting experience in your resume.  Working with an architect designing interior home & office lighting works too.  EE can be taught, using lighting effectively is an acquired skill.

     

    -- John

    • Light_Obsession Novice
      Light_Obsession
      2 posts since
      Feb 6, 2012
      Currently Being Moderated
      Feb 14, 2012 3:32 PM (in response to John63)
      What makes an electrical engineer GOOD at lighting design.

      Good point, the artsy side + technical side make you well rounded.

       

      What about lighting applications that seem to have less room for artistic expression... I'm talking about street lighting, site lighting, and of course custom power distribution systems. Now THAT'S a lighting designer. These types of lighting applications strike me as the type where a technical background is step 1, then an artsy flair can come in 2nd. But without the fundamental technical skills in place already, work will need to be re-worked, wasting time and resources. Is  there someone who has both sides of the coin? Is there SOMEONE with the electrical engineering background who should have been in art class/interior decorating class??

      • John63 Novice
        John63
        10 posts since
        Feb 10, 2012
        Currently Being Moderated
        Feb 16, 2012 12:04 PM (in response to Light_Obsession)
        What makes an electrical engineer GOOD at lighting design.

        OK, as far as I know, the USDOT sets the standards for street lighting, so there is not much wiggle room, except maybe for large manufacturers with new proposed systems (States and local Governments follow the DOT standards - especially if any Federal funding is involved).  This means that most systems are fairly stock, so it is just a matter of picking them out of a catalog.  I'm not sure there is much original design work there, again with the exception of the manufacturers like GE, Siemens, Westinghouse, etc.  Plus, probably a lot of that work is going on overseas these days (e.g., LEDs).  I know what you are trying to get into, but my point is that not much of it requires an EE.  Most of the people I work with are either CEs or MEs.

         

        -- John

More Like This

  • Retrieving data ...

Bookmarked By (0)